EDITING AND REVIEWING PROCESS
of INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE
(description of quality control system)
All manuscripts submitted for publication in «INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE » (IJЕS) are peer reviewed.
Editing and reviewing process. More
The review procedure for manuscripts involves the following steps:
- Review of the manuscript by a member of the Editorial Board (single-blind review– the Reviewer knows the Author, but the Author does not know the Reviewer).
All manuscripts are first reviewed by the IJЕS Technical Editor to evaluate their relevance to the Journal’s directions and requirements. Incomplete materials or manuscripts that do not meet these guidelines are returned to the Author(s) with suggestions for correction. The Authors will be notified by a corresponding letter after the manuscript has been registered in the Editorial Office.
The Editor-in-Chief or Editor of IJЕS reads every submitted manuscript and assigns a general priority level:
(1) the manuscript is sent to Reviewers immediately;
(2) the manuscript is returned to the Authors with suggestions for correction of the submitted data;
(3) the manuscript is rejected.
Editors analyze the revised manuscript. If the manuscript meets the IJЕS requirements, it will be sent to two (or more) Reviewers for analysis and the Statistical Editor if it contains numerical data. The preliminary assessment process usually takes 3 weeks.
II. The manuscript is then submitted for review to an independent expert in the relevant field. This is where double-blind reviewing is used (double-blind review– neither the Author nor the Reviewer know each other). We promise to conceal always the identity of both the Reviewers and the Author from both the parties.
To facilitate this steps of peer review, authors must ensure that their manuscripts are prepared in such a way that they do not disclose the identity of the author. Please provide the following information when submitting the materials: submit a cover page containing information about the authors, and a "manuscript" without any details about the author as 2 separate files.
Reviewing the manuscript, the Reviewers recommend:
(1) Accept without revision;
(2) Accept after revision;
Manuscript Evaluation Process (Reviewer Evaluation Form)
All manuscripts that have been submitted to the Editorial Board go through a peer review procedure. The Reviewers fill out the Reviewer Evaluation Form, which they submit to the IJЕS Editorial Review Board.
In case of disagreement between reviewers, the matter is resolved by the IJЕS Editor-in-Chief.
Authorship Statement (Author Agreement Form)
All authors complete the Author Agreement Form, which must be completed, signed and submitted with the manuscript. Thus, the authors confirm the originality of the manuscript, authorship, assignment, and assert adherence to the review process, that is, they will not remove the manuscript. Completed Agreement Forms must be sent, otherwise the editorial editing of the manuscript may be delayed.
Conflict of interests (Conflict of Interest Declaration)
All authors complete the Conflict of Interest Declaration. Authors should disclose at the time of submission any financial arrangement they may have. Such information will be held in confidence while the manuscript is under review and will not influence the editorial decision, but if the manuscript is accepted for publication, the editors will usually discuss with the authors the manner in which such information is to be communicated to the reader. Because the essence of reviews and editorials is selection and interpretation of the literature, journal expects that authors of such manuscripts will not have any financial interest in a company (or its competitor) that makes a product discussed in the manuscript. Journal policy requires that reviewers, associate editors, editors reveal in a letter to the Editor-in-Chief any relationships that they have that could be construed as causing a conflict of interest with regard to a manuscript under review. The letter should include a statement of any financial relationships with commercial companies involved with a product under study.